Fresh Bread, Real Flavor: Why Scott’s Deli Won Me Over

Written By: Felecia Causey 

Photography: Felecia Causey

I finally made my way to Scott’s Deli in downtown Montgomery after hearing so many people rave about it. As someone who loves a fresh deli sandwich, I was curious—but also cautious. Let’s be real: sometimes places get hyped up by influencers and locals, and when you finally visit, it’s a total letdown. I’ve had my share of wasted time and money chasing recommendations that didn’t live up to the buzz.

When I pulled up, the first thing I noticed was the limited parking. If you’re planning to go, especially around lunchtime, be prepared to search for a spot. I went early, which helped me avoid the crowd and grab a space without any hassle.

Walking into the building, I was struck by its old-school charm. It’s not one of those trendy, modern spots with sleek decor and curated playlists. Instead, it has a nostalgic feel that I genuinely appreciated. It reminded me of places where the food speaks louder than the atmosphere.

I was greeted by Josh, who made my sandwich. He was incredibly patient and kind, especially since it was my first time and I wasn’t familiar with the menu. I decided to go with their club sandwich, and while ordering, I noticed they also had banana pudding and macadamia cookies—so naturally, I had to try those too. They accept both cash and card, which is always convenient. The cashier wasn’t rude, but he wasn’t exactly warm either. I did spot the owners, though I didn’t get a chance to chat with them. I always love hearing the story behind a business—it adds depth to the experience and makes the food feel more personal.

Now let’s talk about the sandwich. The moment I picked it up, I could feel the softness of the bread—and we all know that if the bread isn’t right, the whole sandwich falls apart. Thankfully, this one was perfect. The bread was fresh, the meats were flavorful, and the veggies were crisp. I added oil, vinegar, mayo, and mustard, and the combination was spot-on. Compared to my last visit to Subway, Scott’s Deli was a breath of fresh air. This sandwich officially earned a spot on my go-to list.

The banana pudding was creamy a little too soft for my personal taste, but still enjoyable. The macadamia cookie looked darker than usual, and I thought it might be burnt, but looks can be deceiving. It was soft, sweet, and actually pretty good. 

I didn’t have to wait long since I went right after they opened, but I’ve heard from others that around lunchtime, the place gets packed. If you’re like me and not a fan of long lines, try going early to beat the rush. Josh made my sandwich quickly, and the overall experience was smooth and enjoyable.

Out of five stars, I’d give Scott’s Deli a solid 4.5. Great food, nostalgic atmosphere, and friendly service. I’ll definitely be going back—and if you’re in the area and craving a fresh deli sandwich, I highly recommend giving them a try.